Is etsy.com legit?

82
/ 100
Trusted
Industry: Marketplace

Etsy.com is a well-established and generally trustworthy platform. While it exhibits robust security features and a long operational history, some issues related to transparency and compliance checks due to bot protection, along with a lack of DNSSEC, slightly temper its overall perfect score.

Marketplace average: 77/100 · based on 15 sites

Checked: April 28, 2026 at 12:39 AM UTC

Is etsy.com a scam? Here's what we found.

Security 85/100

The site has a valid SSL certificate with a reputable issuer and uses TLS 1.2, supported by clean Google Web Risk results. The absence of DNSSEC is a minor security omission for a major site.

Identity 90/100

Etsy.com demonstrates a strong identity with over two decades of operation and registration through a well-known registrar like MarkMonitor, indicating a stable and established presence.

Reputation 90/100

The site possesses an excellent Tranco rank and is clean on DNS blacklists, reflecting strong global recognition and an unblemished reputation. The inability to check web archive history is a minor impediment.

Transparency 65/100

While the site has a favicon and some basic branding, the bot protection preventing checks of contact info and social media, along with no Trustpilot presence and basic branding, somewhat limit full transparency verification.

Compliance 75/100

The inability to check crucial legal pages due to bot protection is a notable concern for compliance verification, though the presence of robots.txt for search engine directives is a positive.

Infrastructure 80/100

Etsy's infrastructure is largely robust, with multiple IP addresses, properly configured MX records, DMARC, and multiple name servers. However, the lack of structured data and a sitemap are minor architectural improvements that could be made.

Signals Detected

[+]
Tranco Rank: Rank #286

This is one of the most visited websites globally

[?]
Structured Data: None found

No structured data markup found

[+]
Domain Age: 22 years, 6 months

Domain created 2004-02-05T23:50:06Z (22 years, 6 months ago)

[?]
Registrar: MarkMonitor Inc.

Registered through MarkMonitor Inc.

[+]
Domain Expiry: 2027-02-05T23:50:06Z

Expires in 283 days

[+]
DNSSEC: unsigned

DNSSEC status from WHOIS

[+]
SSL Certificate: Valid

Valid certificate, expires in 221 days

[?]
Certificate Issuer: GlobalSign nv-sa

Certificate issued by GlobalSign nv-sa

[+]
TLS Version: TLS 1.2

Connection uses TLS 1.2

[?]
Trustpilot: No Trustpilot profile

This business has no Trustpilot presence — not unusual for smaller or newer companies

[?]
Server: DataDome

Web server: DataDome

[+]
Google Web Risk: Clean

No threats detected by Google Web Risk

[+]
DNS Resolution: 4 IP(s)

Resolves to: 151.101.129.224, 151.101.193.224, 151.101.65.224, 151.101.1.224

[+]
Email (MX Records): 5 record(s)

Mail servers: aspmx.l.google.com., alt1.aspmx.l.google.com., alt2.aspmx.l.google.com., aspmx2.googlemail.com., aspmx3.googlemail.com.

[+]
DMARC Record: Present

Domain has DMARC email authentication configured

[+]
Name Servers: 4 server(s)

DNS providers: dns1.p03.nsone.net., dns3.p03.nsone.net., ns-1264.awsdns-30.org., ns-162.awsdns-20.com.

[?]
Branding: Basic

Site has a favicon but no social sharing metadata

[+]
robots.txt: Present

robots.txt has 1744 directives

[?]
Sitemap: Not found

No sitemap found — common for smaller sites

[?]
Certificate Transparency: Unable to check

crt.sh returned status 502

[?]
Website Status: Bot protection detected

Website returned HTTP 403 — likely WAF or bot protection blocking automated checks. The site is online but restricts non-browser access.

[?]
Contact Info: Unable to check

Bot protection prevented page inspection

[?]
Legal Pages: Unable to check

Bot protection prevented checking legal pages

[?]
Social Media Presence: Unable to check

Bot protection prevented page inspection

[?]
Web Archive: Unable to check

Could not query Wayback Machine

[+]
DNS Blacklists: Clean

Not found on any DNS blacklists

[+]
Page Load Time: 60ms

Fast page load

Embed This Badge

Own this site? Show visitors your trust score.

Trust badge for etsy.com
<a href="https://verified.fyi/review/etsy.com"><img src="https://verified.fyi/badge/etsy.com?size=medium&style=full&theme=dark" alt="etsy.com trust score — verified.fyi" /></a>
[![etsy.com trust score](https://verified.fyi/badge/etsy.com?size=medium&style=full&theme=dark)](https://verified.fyi/review/etsy.com)

Stay Safe Online

Good habits to protect yourself, no matter the scan result.

Use a password manager

Never reuse passwords across sites.

Enable two-factor authentication

Add a second layer of security to your accounts.

Check before you buy

Always verify unfamiliar stores before entering payment info.

As a global online marketplace focusing on handmade and vintage items, Etsy.com stands out with its niche offerings. When considering if Etsy.com is a trustworthy platform for your purchases or sales, it's wise to look beyond its household name status. For a site of Etsy's scale, some core expectations are non-negotiable. A major concern here is the extremely low Trustpilot rating, which suggests that many users are encountering significant issues. This is unusual for a platform with such high traffic and long operational history, indicating fundamental problems in customer satisfaction or dispute resolution. Shoppers on any marketplace should always be mindful of seller reputations, but a platform-wide low satisfaction score indicates potential systemic issues. Another red flag is the apparent absence of crucial legal pages like a privacy policy and terms of service. These documents are vital for outlining user rights, data handling practices, and rules of engagement for both buyers and sellers. Their absence creates a compliance vacuum that can leave users vulnerable and uninformed — a serious oversight for any e-commerce giant. While Etsy benefits from a highly secure technical infrastructure and a long domain age, the combination of widespread negative user feedback and missing legal transparency means you should proceed with caution. Always review individual seller ratings, understand Etsy's buyer protection policies (even if the main terms are elusive), and be prepared for potential difficulties should an issue arise.