The Surfer's Journal has been around since 1996 — that alone sets it apart from fly-by-night operations. As a reader-supported surf publication, it combines editorial content with a store selling gear, books, and back issues. Most established magazines of this kind have a similar setup: clear contact info, privacy and terms pages, and active social media. Surfersjournal.com ticks all those boxes.
The one technical note worth mentioning is the large number of external scripts running on the site. For a WooCommerce shop, some analytics and plugin scripts are normal, but 64 is on the high side. That doesn't make the site unsafe, but it's something to be aware of if you're privacy-conscious.
Overall, surfersjournal.com reviews from the web and its own long history point to a legitimate business. If you're wondering 'is surfersjournal.com a scam,' the evidence says no — this is the real deal, an independent magazine with a loyal readership.