
The checkout page is the one moment a fake shop actually needs you. Everything before it, the product photos, the reviews, the countdown banner, exists to get you to type a card number into a form. So it's worth knowing what that page can and can't tell you, and what to check in the half minute before you pay.
The short version: read the address, not the padlock; notice who is actually taking the money; and pay in a way you can reverse.
The padlock is not a verdict
The padlock, and the https:// in front of the address, mean one thing: the connection between your browser and the site is encrypted, so nobody on the network in between can read what you type. They don't tell you who is on the other end.
Google found this misunderstanding so persistent that it stopped showing the padlock. Its own research in 2021 found that only 11% of people correctly understood what the icon meant, and Chrome replaced it from version 117 with a neutral "tune" icon that doesn't suggest trustworthiness.
Scammers had worked this out years earlier. Certificates are free and issued automatically: Let's Encrypt, the largest issuer, only checks that the applicant controls the domain, not who they are. By 2019 the Anti-Phishing Working Group was reporting a sharp rise in phishing sites using certificates, and today a phishing page without one is the exception. A padlock on a fake checkout is normal.
So treat a missing padlock as a hard stop, and a present one as no information at all.
Read the address, character by character
The domain in the address bar is the one thing a fake shop can't copy. The logo, the layout, the footer links and even the cookie banner can be cloned pixel for pixel; the real domain can't be registered twice.
Look at the part just before the first single slash, and read it right to left from there:
- The registrable domain is the last two parts (or three, for endings like
.co.uk).paypal.com.secure-checkout.topbelongs to whoever ownssecure-checkout.top, not PayPal. - Watch for swapped letters and lookalike characters:
rnform,0foro,lforI, or letters from other alphabets that render identically. - Brand plus a word is not the brand:
nike-outlet-sale.comandamazon-orders-help.nethave nothing to do with Nike or Amazon.
It is normal for checkout to move to another website, as long as it's a payment company you recognise. Many shops hand payment to a hosted page such as Stripe Checkout, which runs on checkout.stripe.com, or to PayPal. What isn't normal is moving to an address you don't recognise, or one that imitates the shop's own name with something added.
If anything about the address bothers you, open a new tab, type the shop's address yourself, and start again from there. A link you were sent in a text or an ad can be anything; an address you typed is the shop.
Check who is taking the money
A real business leaves traces that a throwaway shop doesn't, and a few of them are visible from the checkout:
- The certificate's owner. Click the icon to the left of the address and open the certificate details. Most sites use domain-validated certificates, which name only the domain, so this proves little on its own. But if a certificate names an organisation, the certificate authority checked that organisation exists, and it should be the business you think you're paying. Browsers stopped showing that name in the address bar in 2019, starting with Chrome 77 and Firefox 70, so you have to look for it.
- Trust badges you can click. A security or review badge is just an image unless clicking it opens a verification page, on the badge provider's own website, that names this shop. A badge that doesn't click through, or opens a page on the shop's own domain, is decoration.
- A name on the payment form. Card payment pages and PayPal approvals usually show the merchant name you're paying. If it doesn't match the shop, stop.
Then notice what the page asks for. A checkout needs your card number, expiry date, security code and a delivery address. It never needs your online banking password, a one-time code read out over the phone, or a crypto wallet's recovery phrase. A page asking for any of those is not a checkout.
What the bank's approval prompt does and doesn't mean
When your bank app pops up asking you to approve a payment, or texts you a code, that's 3-D Secure, the card networks' version of the strong customer authentication that UK and EU rules require for most online card payments. It proves to your bank that you are making the payment.
It does not vouch for the shop. A fraudulent merchant with a working card account triggers the same prompt as a real one. Read what the prompt says, though: it shows the merchant name and the amount. If either doesn't match what you expected, decline it. And never read a code from one of those prompts to someone on the phone. Your bank will never ask for it.
Pay in a way you can reverse
The payment method is your safety net if every other check fails, so it's worth choosing deliberately with a shop you don't know.
- Credit cards are the strongest. In the US, the Fair Credit Billing Act caps your liability for unauthorised charges at $50 (FTC guidance). In the UK, Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act makes the card company jointly liable with the seller for purchases over £100 and under £30,000.
- Debit cards are weaker. US debit cards fall under the Electronic Fund Transfer Act, where your liability depends on how fast you report a problem: $50 within two business days, up to $500 within 60 days of your statement, and potentially everything taken after that. In the UK, debit card chargeback is a card scheme rule rather than a legal right, but most banks honour it.
- Gift cards, crypto, wire transfers and payment-app transfers are where scams end up, because they're hard or impossible to reverse. The UK is a partial exception for bank transfers: since 7 October 2024, banks have had to reimburse most victims of bank transfer scams up to £85,000, though they can refuse if you were grossly negligent. The FTC's own advice is blunt: someone who will only take payment that way is telling you it's a scam. A shop with a normal card checkout that suddenly offers a discount for paying by bank transfer is doing the same thing.
Bank transfers: check the name before you send
If you do pay by bank transfer, to a builder, a landlord or an invoice, the check that matters happens in your banking app.
In the UK, Confirmation of Payee asks the recipient's bank whether the name you typed matches the account. You'll see a match, a close match (with the actual account name shown so you can compare), no match, or "unable to check". Anything but a match is the moment to stop and confirm the details by phone, on a number you already had, not one from the email asking you to pay.
The euro area now has the same thing. Under the EU's Instant Payments Regulation, banks in euro countries have had to offer Verification of Payee on every credit transfer since 9 October 2025, free of charge.
Businesses meet the same trick at a larger scale: an email, apparently from a supplier or an employee, asking to change the bank details on file before the next invoice or payroll run. Name checks catch some of these. Callback rules catch more, and so does software built for technology-driven red flag detection in payroll and HR requests, which looks for the patterns these change requests share.
If you run the shop
The same checks apply in reverse: your customers can only judge your checkout by what they see. A few things make a genuine shop easier to tell apart:
- Keep checkout on your own domain or a processor's. Sending customers through an unfamiliar third domain looks exactly like the scams they've been warned about.
- Let a hosted payment page take the card. How your payment gateway integration is built decides whether card numbers ever touch your server. A hosted page or embedded fields from your processor keep them off it, which shrinks your PCI DSS obligations and the damage a breach of your site could do.
- Make your badges checkable. Link each trust or review badge to the provider's verification page for your shop, and show the company name and registration number your customers can look up.
Check the shop before you get to checkout
The best time to doubt a shop is before you've spent twenty minutes filling a basket. verified.fyi runs the checks above, and many you can't do by eye, as soon as you paste an address. That includes:
- whether the domain imitates a well-known site;
- whether the homepage asks for card details, passwords or a wallet recovery phrase;
- whether its trust badges link anywhere that confirms them;
- whether the certificate names a checked organisation;
- whether its payment, analytics or contact accounts are shared with sites already flagged for phishing or malware.
The methodology explains how each one is scored.
For the wider picture of spotting a fake shop, see how to tell if a website is legit and our guide to fake shopping sites. If the page that worries you arrived by email or text, start with phishing.
If you've already paid
Call the number on the back of your card, report the payment as fraud, and ask for the card to be cancelled and replaced; the sooner you do, the more protection applies. Change the password on any account you used the same password for. Then report the site, so it can be taken down for the next person: ReportFraud.ftc.gov in the US, Report Fraud in England, Wales and Northern Ireland (which replaced Action Fraud in December 2025), or Police Scotland on 101.