Articles

How to Spot a Fake Online Shop

Fake shops borrow photos, invent family backstories and fake their reviews. How to spot one, scam Shopify stores included, before you pay.

verified.fyi
10 min read
On this page

A shopping bag sits on a gift-wrapped trapdoor that opens into a dark hollow.

A fake online shop doesn't need to look fake. It has a logo, a returns page, a wall of five-star reviews and a padlock, and it reaches you through the same adverts as real brands. In the US, shopping scams were the most reported scam on social media in 2025, and more than 40% of people who lost money to a scam that started there said it began when they ordered something they'd seen in an ad. Most said the goods never arrived. Others got counterfeits, or something very different from the advert.

What a fake shop can't easily fake is time, or a real business behind the website. Most of the checks below look for one or the other, and none takes more than a couple of minutes.

Three kinds of fake shop

They work differently, so they give themselves away differently.

Shops that never deliver. These exist to take a payment or a card number. In 2024 researchers at SRLabs traced one network, which they named BogusBazaar, to more than 75,000 shop domains. Since 2021, over 850,000 people, mostly in western Europe and the US, had placed orders with it worth more than $50 million in total. The shops sold brand-name shoes and clothes cheaply; most buyers received nothing, and the shops harvested the card details typed into them.

Clones. A clone copies a real retailer: its name, logo, product pages and checkout, on an address made to be mistaken for the real one. The UK's National Cyber Security Centre warns that these copies can be hard to tell from the genuine store.

Ghost stores. A dropshipper poses as a local, family-run boutique, with a closing-down sale and a sad story about why. Australia's consumer regulator, the ACCC, received at least 360 reports about 60 of these retailers in the first half of 2025. They found customers through Facebook and Instagram ads, ran webstores that appeared to use Shopify, and sent cheap, mass-produced goods at inflated prices. The UK's Advertising Standards Authority describes the same pattern: AI-generated images of the supposed owner, closing-down sales "citing tragic or dramatic reasons" and fake Trustpilot reviews. Something does usually arrive. Sending it back is the problem: the FTC heard from buyers whose goods were shipped from China, with return postage so expensive that returns were unworkable.

How fake shops find you

Mostly through adverts. The FTC found that many of the ads behind shopping scams led to unfamiliar websites, and others to sites impersonating well-known brands with big discounts. BogusBazaar leaned on search instead, using expired domains that still had a good reputation with Google.

Emails and texts do the rest. A "last chance" sale from a brand you like, sent from an address that isn't theirs, relies on the same phishing email tactics as a fake bank alert: a familiar logo, a deadline and a link. Our guide to phishing covers the message itself.

The safest habit is not to buy through the link at all. Type the brand's address yourself, or search for it and check which result you're opening, rather than "just click the top item", as the NCSC puts it.

Buying on a big marketplace is different. Marketplaces screen what their sellers list, increasingly with AI tools, and they stand between you and the seller when an order goes wrong. A stand-alone shop you reach from an advert has nobody checking it before it takes its first order.

Start with the address and the domain's age

The address is the one part of a clone that can't be copied, because a domain can only be registered once. Our guide to checking a payment page explains how to read one character by character. For shops, two more patterns matter. A brand plus a word (brandname-outlet.com) is not the brand. And a place name proves nothing: the ACCC's ghost stores put Australian city names on .com addresses rather than .com.au.

The ending matters a little. .shop sounds made for a shop, but in Interisle Consulting's data for May 2024 to April 2025, a .shop domain was about five times as likely as a .com to be reported for phishing, and a .top domain about 18 times. Plenty of honest shops use both. It's a reason to look harder, not a verdict.

Then check the age. ICANN's lookup shows when any domain was registered, and that date is the most telling single fact about a shop. Across 21,433 sites with a known registration date, 64% of the sites we rated Dangerous were less than a month old. To check that wasn't just our scoring talking, we looked at Google's Web Risk threat list, which our scoring has no say over: sites under a week old were on it 4.9% of the time, sites over five years old 0.05%. Meanwhile 93% of the dangerous newborn sites had a valid padlock.

Two caveats. A young domain isn't proof of anything: real businesses launch new sites every day. And an old domain isn't a pass, because scammers buy expired ones to inherit their history, as BogusBazaar did. The Wayback Machine shows what an address used to be. If it was a plumber's website until last spring, today's shoe shop is someone new.

The age also catches the commonest lie on a fake shop's About page: "family business since 1998" on a domain registered last month, with nothing in the archive.

Look for what was copied

Fake shops are assembled from parts, and finding where a part came from is often the quickest proof.

  • Product photos. Run one through Google Lens or TinEye. The ACCC lists product photos taken from other sites, where the same items sell for less, as a ghost-store sign. If the "handmade" jumper turns up on AliExpress or Temu at a fraction of the price, you've found the supplier and the markup.
  • Faces. Do the same with the founder's portrait and the customers beside the testimonials. Ghost stores use AI-generated owners; other fake shops use portraits from services that hand out faces for design mock-ups. A face that turns up on a dozen other shops belongs to none of them.
  • Policies. Copy a distinctive sentence from the returns policy into a search engine, in quotation marks. Wording that appears on dozens of unrelated shops is a template, and a copied policy sometimes still names the shop it was copied from. Read the details too. The ACCC flags returns that go to an overseas warehouse and terms that cite foreign law.

Check there's a business behind it

A real shop can be traced to someone. A fake one hopes you won't try.

Contact details. Look for a phone number and a street address; the ACCC counts the lack of either as a warning sign. Then look the address up. The ASA's ruling on Marble Muse, a clothing site with a "BRITISH BRAND" banner, a Union Jack and a story about being "founded in London", found its London address appeared to be a home on a housing estate, while returns went to a warehouse in Asia.

The company register. UK businesses can be found on Companies House, Australian ones on ABN Lookup, and EU VAT numbers can be checked on VIES. Check the name as well as the number, because fake shops print real companies' numbers. In our research, sites under a month old listed company details more often than sites over five years old (30% against 19%). A company number takes one copy and paste.

The social page. The ASA suggests checking the shop's Facebook or Instagram account: when it was set up, whether it has changed its name, and where it's managed from. A page renamed twice this year and run from another country isn't a family boutique.

Read the reviews somewhere else

Reviews on a shop's own pages say whatever the shop wants them to. The ASA found ghost stores showing fake Trustpilot reviews on their own websites, and the ACCC lists the mirror image as a warning sign: glowing reviews on the shop, negative ones on Trustpilot. So go to the review site yourself, by typing its address, and look the shop up there. Then search the shop's name with "scam" or "complaint", which is the FTC's advice too.

The numbers can give a shop away: 3,000 reviews on a domain registered three weeks ago, or reviews dated before the domain existed. So can a trust badge that doesn't click through to a page confirming it covers this shop.

Fake reviews are illegal on both sides of the Atlantic: in the US since an FTC rule covering reviews by people who don't exist, AI-generated ones included, took effect in October 2024, and in the UK since the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act's ban came into force in April 2025. Neither worries a shop that won't exist next month.

Scam Shopify stores

Shopify is a real company and most shops on it are genuine. But it supplies the software and the checkout; whoever signed up runs the shop. "It's on Shopify" tells you nothing about the merchant, and the help pages for Shopify's Shop app say the store, not Shopify, is responsible for fulfilling your order and for returns and refunds.

What Shopify does hold is a record that sits outside the shop's own pages. Our Shopify store check reads the business address and shipping countries the merchant gave Shopify, and when the shop's oldest product was listed, a date the shop can't change. A "family boutique since 1998" whose first product went up three weeks ago has answered the question for you.

If a Shopify store takes your money and goes quiet, contact the store, then dispute the payment with your bank. Once you dispute it, Shopify is notified and can investigate the store. Report it on Shopify's fraud form too, so it can be taken down for the next buyer.

Shopify's name also turns up in a different scam. In June 2026, researchers at Gen reported fake receipts planted in Shop, Shopify's order-tracking app, often under generic store names such as "My Store", for things like a Norton renewal or an iPhone, with a phone number to call if you didn't place the order. Don't call it. Check your bank app for the charge; if there isn't one, the receipt is the scam.

Pay so you can get it back

When you do buy from a shop you don't know, pay by credit card. Our guide to verifying a payment page covers the checkout itself and which payment methods you can reverse. Two patterns specific to fake shops are worth knowing. BogusBazaar's shops sometimes showed a payment error and then sent buyers to a second payment page, which charged them. And a shop that wants a bank transfer, or offers a discount for one, is steering you away from the protection a card gives you. In the UK, purchase scams, where someone pays by bank transfer for goods that never come, made up 71% of the authorised push payment fraud cases banks reported in 2025.

If you've already paid

Call your bank or card provider straight away, on the number on your card, to stop or dispute the payment, and ask for a new card if you typed the number in. Then report the shop, so it comes down faster for the next person:

What verified.fyi checks on a shop

Paste a shop's address into verified.fyi and it collects 200+ facts about the site from public sources, then scores it 0–100. For shops, the checks that matter most are the ones above, done automatically:

  • Domain age and history: when the domain was registered and how far back the web archive goes.
  • Lookalike address: whether the domain imitates a top website, with lookalike letters, the real domain written in front of another, or the brand next to words like login.
  • Copied site: traces that the pages were copied, such as the marker a site copier leaves, a canonical link or sitemap naming another domain, or policies that call another shop "our website".
  • Borrowed product photos: product photos loading straight from AliExpress, Amazon, Temu or another Shopify store's uploads.
  • Placeholder faces: testimonials or team photos using faces from randomuser.me, pravatar.cc and other mock-up services.
  • Claimed age: a founding year from years before a domain under a year old was registered, when nothing else shows an older business.
  • Review claims: more reviews than a weeks-old domain could have collected, or reviews dated before it was registered.
  • Shopify store record: the address and shipping countries given to Shopify, and when the first product was listed.
  • Company registration: whether the number shown is on the official register, and whether the name or website matches.
  • Shared accounts: whether the shop shares a payment, analytics or live-chat account, a phone number or email address, or its Shopify store with sites already flagged by Google Web Risk or a threat feed. Fake shops come in networks, and one that's been caught gives away the rest.

The methodology explains how each one is scored. For the checks that apply to any website, not just shops, see how to tell if a website is legit.

Wondering about a site right now?

Paste the address — we'll run 200+ checks and give you a plain-English verdict in seconds.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if an online shop is fake?

Check when its domain was registered, reverse-search its product photos, and look the business up on a company register and an independent review site. A shop that is weeks old, borrows its photos from other retailers and can't be traced to a real business shouldn't get your card details.

Are Shopify stores safe to buy from?

Shopify is a genuine platform, but anyone can open a store on it, and the merchant, not Shopify, is responsible for delivering your order and refunding you. Check a Shopify store as you would any other shop, and if one cheats you, dispute the payment with your bank and report the store to Shopify.

What is a clone shopping site?

A fake shop that copies a real retailer's name, logo and product pages onto a lookalike address, to take payments or card details for goods that never arrive. The address is the one thing it can't copy, so type the retailer's address yourself rather than following an ad or a link.

What is a ghost store?

An online shop posing as a local, family-run boutique, usually with a closing-down sale and a sad story about why. Regulators in Australia and the UK describe them as overseas dropshippers sending cheap goods, with returns going to a warehouse abroad.

What should I do if I paid a fake shop?

Call your bank or card provider straight away to stop or dispute the payment, and ask for a new card if you typed the number in. Then report the shop: to Report Fraud in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, Police Scotland on 101, ReportFraud.ftc.gov in the US, and Shopify if the shop ran on it.

More from the blog

View all posts →

Check before you trust

Free, instant, no account needed — paste any site and get a plain-English verdict.

Check a site →