Articles

Fraud Alert vs Credit Freeze: Which One Do You Need?

A fraud alert makes US lenders check it's you; a credit freeze closes your file to new credit. How each works, how to lift one, and what neither stops.

verified.fyi
12 min read
On this page

A coral warning bell beside a credit folder contrasts with a second folder enclosed in a block of ice.

If someone has your name, date of birth and Social Security number, they can try to open credit in your name. In the US, two free tools make that harder. A fraud alert tells lenders to check it's really you before they open an account. A credit freeze stops the credit bureaus from handing your report to a new lender at all.

Both are rights under the US Fair Credit Reporting Act, and both work through the three nationwide credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. Below: how each works, how to lift a freeze, the other files worth freezing, and what neither one stops. The UK, which has no credit freeze, comes at the end.

The difference at a glance

Fraud alert Credit freeze
What it does Lenders must take steps to confirm it's you before opening new credit The bureau won't release your report for new credit until you lift it
Who you contact Any one bureau, which passes it to the other two Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, each separately
How long it lasts 1 year (initial), 7 years (extended), 1 year (active duty) Until you remove it
Cost Free Free to place, lift and remove
When you apply for credit Expect an extra identity check or a phone call Lift it first, at the bureau your lender uses

The FTC calls a freeze the best way to protect against an identity thief opening new accounts in your name. An alert keeps your report open and relies on each lender doing its checks.

How a fraud alert works

A fraud alert is a notice added to your credit file. Under section 605A of the Fair Credit Reporting Act, a lender that sees one may not open a new account in your name, issue an extra card on an existing account or raise a credit limit unless it has taken reasonable steps to make sure the applicant is you. If you gave a phone number when you placed the alert, the lender must call it or verify you some other reasonable way.

You contact one bureau, and the law requires it to pass the alert to the other two. There are three kinds, all free.

Initial fraud alert

Anyone who suspects in good faith that they are, or are about to become, a victim of fraud or identity theft can place one. You don't need proof that anything has happened yet. It lasts one year, up from 90 days before 21 September 2018, and can be renewed.

Extended fraud alert

This one is for confirmed victims. You need an identity theft report: either the FTC's, which you get by reporting at IdentityTheft.gov, or a police report. According to the FTC, it lasts seven years, and renewing it means sending your report again.

The checks are stricter than an initial alert's. Before opening credit, a lender must contact you in person or by the phone number or other contact method you named. The bureaus also leave you off the lists they supply for prescreened credit and insurance offers for five years.

Active duty alert

This is for servicemembers on active duty, and reservists called up to it, who are posted away from their usual duty station. It works like an initial alert, lasts one year and can be renewed for the length of a deployment. It also removes you from prescreened offer lists for two years. Someone acting on your behalf can request it while you're away.

Active duty servicemembers and National Guard members can also get free electronic credit monitoring from each bureau.

How a credit freeze works

A credit freeze, which the law calls a security freeze, stops a bureau from releasing your credit report to anyone deciding whether to give you new credit. Few lenders approve an application without seeing a report, so a freeze blocks most new accounts outright, including ones you apply for yourself until you lift it. Freezes have been free at all three bureaus since 21 September 2018.

Unlike an alert, a freeze doesn't spread from one bureau to the others. You place it three times:

By law, a bureau must place the freeze within one business day of an online or phone request, or three business days after a request by post, and send you confirmation within five business days. It then stays until you remove it. The CFPB points out that a freeze doesn't affect your credit scores in any way, and you can still get your own reports.

Who can still see a frozen report

A freeze is about new credit, not every look at your file. Under federal law, these can still see a frozen report:

  • companies you already have an account with, and debt collectors acting for them;
  • government agencies with a court order, warrant or subpoena, child support agencies, and agencies investigating fraud or collecting unpaid taxes;
  • insurers deciding whether to cover you, and employers, landlords and background screening firms;
  • credit monitoring services you've signed up to;
  • lenders sending you prescreened offers of credit or insurance.

That last one surprises people. To stop prescreened offers, opt out separately at OptOutPrescreen.com or on 1-888-5-OPT-OUT, the route Equifax gives.

Lifting a freeze

Before you apply for a loan, card or mortgage, ask the lender which bureau it checks and lift the freeze only there, then refreeze afterwards. That's the FTC's advice in its 2025 reminder on freezes.

By law, a bureau must lift the freeze within one hour of a request online or by phone, or within three business days of one by post. You can ask for a temporary lift for a period you choose; Experian lets you schedule a "thaw" with start and end dates. If you apply without lifting the freeze, the lender is allowed to treat your application as incomplete.

Freezes and credit locks

The bureaus also offer app-based "locks", which aren't the same thing. The CFPB says locks are often sold for a fee, sometimes bundled with other paid services, and are "no more effective than security freezes, which are free and which you have a right to by law." Experian's CreditLock comes with a paid membership, and Equifax won't let you have a freeze and a lock on the same report. If a site asks you to pay to freeze your credit, it isn't the bureau's freeze.

Which one should you use?

If you aren't planning to borrow, freeze. The FTC says a freeze is something you can do any time, for any reason, and that freezes are generally best for people who aren't planning to take out new credit, often older adults, people under guardianship and children.

If your Social Security number has leaked, freeze. Experian's own advice is that a freeze matters most when your Social Security number may have been accessed, as in a data breach. A card can be cancelled and reissued; your Social Security number stays the same, and a freeze, unlike an alert, has no expiry date.

If you're applying for credit in the next few weeks, an initial alert is the lighter option. It keeps your report open, so a mortgage or car loan goes through with one extra identity check. Lifting a freeze online takes minutes, though, so for most people the freeze still wins once the application is done.

If you're already a victim, use both. An extended alert and a freeze can sit on the same file. The freeze blocks new credit, and the alert means any lender that sees your report after you lift it has to contact you first.

Freezing a child's credit

Children rarely have a credit file, which makes a child's Social Security number attractive: a fraud can run for years before anyone checks. Since 2018, a parent, guardian or child welfare representative can freeze the file of a child under 16 for free. If the bureau has no file, it creates a record just to freeze it, and the FTC says that record can't be used for credit. The same right covers adults who are incapacitated or have a court-appointed guardian.

This one takes paperwork, and you still do it at each bureau separately:

The freeze stays until you remove it, or until the child removes it once they're 16. Lift it before they first apply for credit. Our guide for parents covers judging a website's safety more broadly.

Other files worth freezing

Equifax, Experian and TransUnion aren't the only companies that keep a file on you. A few others can be frozen too, and each freeze covers only that company.

  • ChexSystems keeps records of checking accounts, including ones closed and why, which banks look at when you apply to open one. It offers its own security freeze, which covers only the ChexSystems report. It posts you a PIN that you need later to lift the freeze.
  • NCTUE, the National Consumer Telecom and Utilities Exchange, holds the phone, pay TV and utility account histories its member companies share, and Equifax runs it for them. A freeze is free to place, lift or remove.
  • E-Verify Self Lock covers employment identity theft, where someone works under your Social Security number and their wages are reported in your name. With a myE-Verify account you can lock your number in E-Verify, the federal system some employers use to check the right to work. It's free and stays on until you unlock it, which you should do before starting a job with an employer that uses E-Verify. It doesn't affect employers that don't.

What neither tool stops

Alerts and freezes protect against one thing: new credit opened in your name. Most other identity theft goes straight past them.

Your existing accounts. The CFPB says plainly that a freeze doesn't prevent identity thieves from taking over existing accounts. An alert's legal checks cover new accounts, extra cards and limit increases, not spending on a card that's already open. Transaction alerts from your bank, unique passwords and passkeys do that job.

Tax returns. A thief who files a return under your Social Security number can claim your refund before you do. The IRS Identity Protection PIN is a six-digit number that stops anyone filing a federal return with your Social Security number or ITIN without it. Anyone who can verify their identity can get one, parents can request one for dependants, and a new PIN is issued every calendar year. Fake IRS pages are one way those details leak; our guide to fake IRS websites shows what they look like.

Medical care. Someone using your Medicare or insurance details for treatment never touches your credit file. Medicare.gov advises comparing your Medicare statements with the appointments you actually had, and opening an account there to see claims as soon as they're processed. Statements from a private insurer deserve the same check.

Anything you hand over yourself. A freeze does nothing if you type your card number or bank login into a fake page, and phishing pages exist to collect exactly those details. Our guide to phishing covers how to spot one.

If your identity has already been stolen

Start at IdentityTheft.gov, the FTC's free site. Reporting there gives you a personal recovery plan and the FTC Identity Theft Report that qualifies you for an extended alert.

Then check what's on your files. AnnualCreditReport.com is the only website authorised by federal law to give you your free credit reports, and you can now get one from each bureau every week. Look for accounts, addresses and searches you don't recognise.

Recovery has an order to it. Juggling Chaos sets out the identity theft recovery steps as a checklist, from calling the fraud departments of the companies involved to freezing all three files.

Outside the US: the UK

The UK has no legal credit freeze. Its three main credit reference agencies share their names with the US bureaus, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, but they work under UK law and are licensed by the Financial Conduct Authority. The ICO notes that each lender chooses which agency, if any, to use.

The nearest thing to a fraud alert is Cifas Protective Registration. For £30, it flags your name and personal details in the Cifas National Fraud Database for two years. Organisations that use Cifas data are asked to take extra care when your details appear on an application, and may run extra identity checks. It doesn't block credit, and it doesn't cover card payments.

Experian sells a lock, CreditLock, as part of a paid subscription, but it only blocks applications that go through Experian. A free alternative is a password Notice of Correction: a short note on your file asking lenders to call you for a password before approving credit. You add it with each agency separately.

Either way, check your files. Each agency must give you a statutory report free of charge, and the ICO says to look for that phrase on their websites rather than sign up to a subscription.

Check you're on the real bureau's site

Placing a freeze means typing your Social Security number, date of birth and address into a website, exactly what an identity thief wants, so make sure it's the real one. Type the address yourself rather than following a link from an email, text or ad, or start from the bureau links on IdentityTheft.gov, which the FTC is required by law to maintain. Our current reports on equifax.com, experian.com and transunion.com show what the genuine sites look like to our checks.

For any other site that asks for these details, paste its address into verified.fyi first. Among the 200+ facts it collects, the ones that matter most here are:

  • whether the address imitates a well-known site, with lookalike letters or the real name placed in front of another domain;
  • how old the domain is and who registered it;
  • whether Google Web Risk, abuse.ch or Spamhaus have flagged it for phishing or malware;
  • whether the homepage asks for a password or card details.

The methodology explains how each fact is scored. For the checks you can do by eye, see how to tell if a website is legit.

Wondering about a site right now?

Paste the address — we'll run 200+ checks and give you a plain-English verdict in seconds.

Frequently asked questions

Does a credit freeze or fraud alert hurt my credit score?

No. The CFPB says a freeze does not affect your credit scores in any way, and the FTC says the same. A fraud alert is a notice on your file asking lenders to check your identity, not a record of how you repay.

Do I need to contact all three credit bureaus?

For a freeze, yes: you place it separately with Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, and a freeze at one does nothing at the others. For a fraud alert, no: contact any one of them and the law requires it to pass the alert to the other two.

How long does a fraud alert last?

An initial fraud alert lasts one year and can be renewed. An extended alert, for identity theft victims with an FTC or police report, lasts seven years. An active duty alert lasts one year and can be renewed for the length of a deployment. A freeze lasts until you remove it.

How quickly can I unfreeze my credit?

By law a bureau must lift a freeze within one hour of a request made online or by phone, or within three business days of a request by post. You can set the lift for a period you choose, and you only need to lift it at the bureau your lender uses.

Is there a credit freeze in the UK?

Not as a legal right. The closest equivalents are Cifas Protective Registration, which costs £30 for two years and asks organisations that check Cifas data to take extra care, and a password Notice of Correction on your credit file. Check your free statutory reports from Equifax, Experian and TransUnion as well.

More from the blog

View all posts →

Check before you trust

Free, instant, no account needed — paste any site and get a plain-English verdict.

Check a site →